Preparing for Medicare AEP: Avoid These Common Mistakes

| September 12, 2025

Every year, from October 15 to December 7 , Medicare beneficiaries have the opportunity to review and make changes to their Medicare coverage during the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) . This is the time to compare plans, switch Medicare Advantage or Part D plans, or go back to Original Medicare if your needs have changed.

Unfortunately, many people rush through this process—or skip it entirely—and end up with coverage that doesn’t match their needs. Here are some common mistakes to avoid in 2025 so you can make the most of AEP and avoid unnecessary expenses or disruptions in care.


Mistake #1: Ignoring Your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC)

Your plan may look the same—but that doesn’t mean it is. Each September, your current plan will mail you an Annual Notice of Change that outlines any changes to premiums, drug formularies, provider networks, and copayments.

Why it matters: Even a small change in your prescription coverage or provider network can lead to unexpected costs or loss of access to your doctor.

Tip: Review your ANOC carefully, especially if you have regular prescriptions or see specialists.


Mistake #2: Assuming You Can ‘Set It and Forget It’

Medicare is not one-size-fits-all. Your health needs, finances, and provider preferences can shift from year to year.

Why it matters: A plan that worked for you last year might not be the best choice this year. Formularies change, premiums go up, and networks shift.

Tip: Use Medicare’s official Plan Finder at Medicare.gov/plan-compare to compare plans based on your ZIP code, medications, and preferred providers.


Mistake #3: Missing the Enrollment Window

AEP runs from October 15 through December 7 . Changes you make during this period take effect January 1, 2026 .

Why it matters: If you miss this window, your options may be limited. Unless you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period , you may have to wait until the next AEP to make changes.

Tip: Mark your calendar now and schedule time to review your options—ideally in early October to avoid last-minute stress.


Mistake #4: Not Reviewing Drug Coverage

Even if your medications haven’t changed, your Part D drug plan might have. Drug tiers, prior authorizations, and formularies are updated every year.

Why it matters: A medication you’ve taken for years could suddenly cost more—or be dropped entirely from your plan.

Tip: Make a list of your medications and dosage, then verify coverage under your current or new plan.


Mistake #5: Relying on Outdated Advice

Medicare is constantly evolving. What was true last year may no longer apply in 2025. While friends and family mean well, their advice may not reflect your personal circumstances or current Medicare rules.

Tip: Work with a licensed agent who specializes in Medicare and stays current on policy changes. Be sure they represent multiple carriers so you get objective comparisons.


Mistake #6: Forgetting to Check Your Providers

Provider networks in Medicare Advantage Plans can change annually. Just because your doctor is in-network now doesn’t guarantee they will be next year.

Tip: Confirm your preferred doctors, specialists, and hospitals are still in-network for the upcoming year before you re-enroll.


Bottom Line

The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period is your chance to fine-tune your health coverage and avoid unpleasant surprises in the year ahead. But skipping the review—or assuming nothing has changed—can cost you.

If you need help comparing plans or understanding what’s changed for 2025, we’re here to help . Reach out for a no-obligation review and get confident about your Medicare choices.

Smiling couple looking at laptop in a bright living room, with cat nearby.
By Mike Smith February 18, 2026
Annuities are often misunderstood. Learn the truth behind four common annuity myths and how they can support retirement income.
Couple reviewing financial documents and tablet at a table; they appear focused and concerned.
By Mike Smith February 11, 2026
Learn the most common retirement planning mistakes—from starting too late to underestimating healthcare costs—and how to avoid them.
Two medical professionals reviewing a patient's chart with the patient in a hospital bed.
By Mike Smith February 4, 2026
Medicare hospital coverage has limits. Learn how Medigap plans help cover extended hospital stays and reduce out-of-pocket costs.
Older man pointing at computer screen, woman using a mouse. They are in a well-lit home office.
By Mike Smith October 25, 2025
Don't make costly mistakes during Medicare AEP (Oct 15 - Dec 7)! Learn the 6 common errors to avoid, including ignoring your ANOC and missing the enrollment deadline.
Pile of assorted colorful pills and capsules.
By Mike Smith October 20, 2025
Major Medicare Part D changes arrive in 2026: a $2,100 out-of-pocket cap, new negotiated drug prices (including Eliquis & Jardiance), and the option for monthly payments.
Person's hand being held by another's, seated with stress ball.
October 15, 2025
Learn the difference between long-term care and assisted living. Find out which costs Medicare does and doesn't cover, and why planning ahead for custodial care is essential.
Elderly man smiles, talking on phone while using a laptop outdoors.
September 26, 2025
The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) is coming. Learn what AEP is, key dates for 2026, and how to prepare now to ensure your Medicare plan fits your health and financial needs.
Man holding cupcakes with
September 22, 2025
Turning 65? This comprehensive guide explains everything you need to know about Medicare enrollment, including key deadlines, automatic vs. manual sign-up, how it works with employer coverage, and how to avoid late penalties.
Envelope with
September 16, 2025
Experiencing a denied claim from your Medicare Advantage plan? Learn why these denials are happening and the essential steps you can take to appeal and get the care you need.
By Medicare is Simple July 30, 2025
Imagine getting a call in the middle of the night from someone claiming to be your grandchild, panicked and in trouble. They say they’ve been in an accident or arrested—and they desperately need money. Your heart races. You’d do anything to help. That’s exactly what scammers are counting on. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has recently issued a warning about a rise in what's known as the “grandparent scam” —a sneaky and heartless scheme targeting older adults with urgent, emotional phone calls meant to trick them into sending money. What Is the Grandparent Scam? These scams usually start with a phone call from someone pretending to be your grandchild (or another close relative). They’ll say they’re in trouble—maybe stuck in jail or in a hospital—and they need money fast for bail, legal fees, or emergency expenses. To make things even more convincing, they may hand the phone off to someone pretending to be a lawyer or a police officer. And they’ll likely ask you not to tell anyone—saying it’s a “private” or “sensitive” situation. That sense of urgency is key to the scam. It’s meant to bypass your instinct to double-check and make you act fast—before you have time to think it through or talk to someone else. Why It Works—and Why It’s Dangerous These calls often come late at night or early in the morning, when you’re more likely to be caught off guard. The scammer might not even say who they are—just “Grandma, it’s me”—and hope you fill in the blank for them. From there, they use that information to sound more convincing. Some victims have been asked to send money via wire transfer, cryptocurrency, gift cards, or even in cash via courier—all methods that are difficult or impossible to trace or reverse. According to the FCC, scammers using this method have stolen tens of millions of dollars from seniors across the U.S. Watch for These Warning Signs If you or someone you love receives a call like this, here are some red flags that it could be a scam: High pressure and urgency – You’re told to act immediately Vague or strange details – They may not identify themselves clearly, or hope you’ll say the grandchild’s name for them Unverifiable location or story – They say they’re in jail overseas or in a place where you can’t easily check on them Unusual payment requests – Gift cards, Bitcoin, wire transfers, or cash deliveries Calls at odd hours – Scammers try to catch you when you’re less alert What To Do If You Get a Suspicious Call If something doesn’t feel right, trust your gut. Here’s what you can do to stay safe: ✅ Hang up and verify – Call your grandchild or their parent using a phone number you know is theirs ✅ Talk to someone you trust – A second opinion from a friend or family member can make all the difference ✅ Don’t rely on caller ID – Scammers often “spoof” numbers to make it look like someone you know is calling ✅ Block the number – Use your phone’s settings to block suspicious calls ✅ Report the scam – Contact the National Elder Fraud Hotline at 833-FRAUD-11 and file a complaint with the FCC What If You’ve Already Sent Money? First of all, don’t panic—and know that you’re not alone. Scammers are incredibly convincing, and even smart, cautious people have been tricked. Here’s what to do: Call your bank or payment service right away – They may be able to stop or reverse the transaction if it's recent Report it – Contact the FCC, your local police, and the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov Let your family know – They can help protect you and others from future attempts Help Protect Others, Too The more people know about this scam, the harder it becomes for criminals to succeed. Please share this information with friends, neighbors, and especially your older loved ones. A quick conversation now could prevent a heartache later. And remember—if you ever get a call like this and aren’t sure what to do, don’t rush. Take a breath, hang up, and check in with someone you trust. Real family emergencies don’t come with secret demands or payments via gift cards.
Show More